On the other side of my diocese, they’re hoisting chianti and offering some sage thoughts on the motu proprio over at Deacon Tony’s Place.

I think Tony gets it right:

Here Benedict is trying to make an appeal to regain the mystery and awe once experienced in the traditional mass that was somehow lost in the last four decades following the council. Many traditionalists argue that the mass was transformed from a Holy Sacrifice to a communal meal celebration. They also charge that the celebrant (presider) and his choreographed inventions have replaced Jesus’ sacrificial act on Calvary. Both Benedict and his predecessor have heard the complaints and tried to ignite the “reform of the reform” by issuing Redemptionis Sacramentum(2004) and Sacramentum Caritatis (2007).

I firmly believe the the mystery, awe and unity that is needed can also be achieved in the Paul VI Mass as well. How many of us complain how parishioners don’t respond to the prayers (in the vernacular), how many parishioners don’t sing, how many parishioners rarely stay for the entire mass? We need to pray that our liturgy, which calls for the full, conscious, and active participation (especially internally) of all those assembled becomes a reality. Then we can truly experience heaven on earth. Then we can truly experience the mystery of God. Now we need less letters and more action. Bishops, priests, deacons & laity need to work together and implement Vatican II and the instructions of JP2 and B16 to the fullest.

Let’s pray that this important document is received in the spirit in which it was delivered — and that the great mystery of our lives, the holy mass, will continue to nourish and sustain the faithful everywhere, in every language, and in every rite.