I finally bit the bullet and went to see “Eragon,” the first of three films based on the bestselling “Inheritance” trilogy by Christopher Paolini. Paolini is a shockingly young (i.e., born in 1983) author who took the book world by storm as a teenager with the release of “Eragon,” a novel he began writing at age 16. He quickly followed up that much-heralded debuted with “Eldest,” Book Two of the trilogy. (Book Three is yet to come.) I haven’t read the novel–unusual for me, given that I am an utter fantasy geek, but only because I’ve heard from too many trusted writer-reader friends that “Eragon” is an impressive piece of work, for a teenager. In other words, not the best read for an adult.

But I figured it was worth my money at the box office, at least.

“Eragon” the film has all the trimmings of a true fantasy epic: a young, handsome farm boy who has a great destiny before him and must rise to the occasion; a mentor who will help him get there; arduous journeys; the triumph of evil over good–for now (we know that all that will change, of course); a one-dimensional villain-king; an evil sorcerer; magical creatures; and, last but not least, a beautiful warrior-princess, whom we all know is destined for our hero.

So, in many ways it was fun as a film, but I couldn’t help myself from checking off, one-by-one, the formulaic ingredients that Paolini made sure to include in his plot, making it clearly a member of the “classic” fantasy genre. At moments, I secretly delighted in thinking: A-ha! This is the “Harry Potter” bit here (a scar that marks our hero’s destiny and one that burns when danger is near). And a-ha! This is the “Lord of the Rings” bit now (well, basically the whole movie takes after Tolkien, complete with a Saruman-type bad wizard, his own dark stronghold with an army of weapon-building grotesque orc-like creatures, and lots of journeying across hills, etc. on horseback). And, no way! There’s even some “Star Wars” moments thrown in for good measure (think: oh no! Not my uncle!).

But when you think this was all imagined by a teenager, you have to admit: impressive indeed. He included all the proper fantasy ingredients, with even a little imagination of his own thrown in. So the movie is a nice afternoon activity. But the book, weighing in at a hefty 538 pages–I’m not sure I am geeky enough to give it a go.

Join our mailing list to receive more stories like this delivered daily!
By filling out the form above, you will be signed up to receive Beliefnet's Daily Bible Reading newsletter and special partner offers. You may opt-out any time.
More from Beliefnet and our partners